On a Friday night at 121 Second Avenue, the wood-fired oven on the patio stays lit until 9 p.m. A few blocks east, the address where Lefty's sold pizza and ice cream for 25 years now has a claw machine in the lobby of a dental office. Around the corner on Franklin Street, the yellow Bader House that Colterra once used for events has a counseling practice inside.
Three of Old Town Niwot's best-known restaurant addresses have changed hands, and only the 1914 House building has a kitchen again. The way it came back explains a lot about the other two. Two more Old Town lots were in early redevelopment as of the Courier's last update in December 2025, and both have plans for ground floors that could hold a restaurant or an office.
The 1914 House came back with a new arrangement
The restaurant at 121 Second Avenue closed at the end of July 2024 after eight years. When owner Nick Mastronardi announced it, he told the Left Hand Valley Courier that "expenses have collectively escalated to levels that exceed our ability to increase prices." He listed property taxes, utilities, labor and food costs, along with a large sanitation-district rate increase on a building that uses 10 sewer taps.
The property tax figures he gave put the problem in numbers. Real estate taxes on the property were just under $15,000 in 2014. Ten years later they were over $46,000, with another $9,000 in personal property taxes on equipment and furniture that year. He also named the Boulder County minimum wage, since the restaurant employed several high school students.
Mastronardi kept the building. In April 2026 the Courier reported that he was leasing it to the Laudisio family, so he became the landlord rather than the operator. Antonio Laudisio opened Laudisio Ristorante Italiano on Iris Avenue in Boulder in 1987. Justin Hirshfield, who was executive chef at the 1914 House, is back running the kitchen.
The new place is also deliberately smaller in scope. "We've done white tablecloth, upscale dining before," Laudisio told the Courier, describing a small menu of comforting Italian dishes and rotating "memory meal" specials. He described it as "a place residents can gather two to three times a week."
Taverna Laudisio started with limited evening service on June 18, 2026, the Courier reported, with wood-fired pizza and weekend small plates coming from the patio oven. The spring announcement mentioned full lunch and dinner service "over the coming months." For now the restaurant serves dinner only. The posted hours are:
- Wednesday, Thursday and Sunday: 4 to 8:30 p.m.
- Friday and Saturday: 4 to 9 p.m.
- Monday and Tuesday: closed
The menu runs from antipasti and salads to house-made pasta, secondi and desserts.
Where each old dining room ended up
The 1914 House is the only one of these buildings serving food again. Here is what happened at each address, using the most recent local reporting:
| Address | Former use | What's there or planned now |
|---|---|---|
| 121 Second Avenue | 1914 House restaurant | Taverna Laudisio, dinner Wednesday through Sunday |
| 364 Second Avenue | Lefty's, then Niwot Pizza | Niles Family Dentistry, open since Sept. 1, 2026, in a new two-story building that also has commercial space |
| 210 Franklin Street | Colterra and the Bader House | Dignity Counseling & Wellness in the Bader House; a five-unit mixed-use building under construction next to it as of December 2025 |
| 291 Second Avenue | Niwot Rental and Feed | Approved 9,426-square-foot mixed-use building with four upstairs homes and ground-floor retail, restaurant or office space |
| 124 Second Avenue | Few of a Kind Vintage + Mercantile | Basin Design + Build studio |
The 124 Second Avenue change was retail, not a restaurant. Still, the Courier reported that the vintage shop planned to close at the end of April 2026 to make room for Basin's design studio, which fits the same pattern of shopfronts becoming offices.
364 Second Avenue took seven years to become an office
The Lefty's site did not change overnight. Here is how it went, according to the Courier's December 2025 construction roundup and its October 2026 opening story:
- 2019. Ashley Niles Properties, LLC buys the property, which had been Lefty's Gourmet Pizza and Ice Cream for 25 years.
- 2023. Boulder County approves a site plan for a two-story commercial building, and a modification follows in 2024.
- 2025. Niwot Pizza moves to Longmont as redevelopment gets close. The original building comes down, and the foundation is poured by December.
- Sept. 1, 2026. Niles Family Dentistry opens, moving from 136 Second Avenue.
The new office keeps some of the old address's history. The treatment rooms are named for Niwot landmarks, including the Niwot Inn, the Market, the Tavern and The Wheel House, and one room is named for Lefty's. The practice went from six chairs to eight. The building also has commercial space beyond the dental office.
The pizza moved to Ken Pratt Boulevard
The restaurant that used to be at 364 still exists. Lorenzo Villalobos cooked at Lefty's for 24 years before he and his wife, Maricela Vazquez, took over the business as Niwot Pizza. They first moved to north Longmont. On Aug. 25, 2026, they moved again to 950 Elgin Avenue, Suite B, just east of the Safeway on Ken Pratt Boulevard, the Courier reported.
"I'm closer to Niwot. So the old customers come back," Villalobos told the Courier. He kept "Niwot" in the name as a tribute to the original location, and the Lefty's Pizza fountain moved with him. Niwot Pizza delivers to Niwot and Gunbarrel, businesses included, through DoorDash.
The old favorites are still on the menu, including Mary's Margherita, Elise's Ecstasy and the Thai Pie. November's Pizza of the Month is a birria pizza with green chile, cilantro, onions and tomatillo sauce.
Two redevelopment lots have plans that allow food, offices or shops
The next additions to Old Town are planned for two lots that were last reported at early stages of redevelopment in December 2025. Both plans pair homes with ground-floor commercial space, and neither commits that space to a restaurant.
210 Franklin Street. Colterra closed after a fire in fall 2017, and the whole property sat empty until the counseling office opened. Dignity Counseling & Wellness took the historic Bader House in early summer 2025 and began seeing clients that September, the Courier reported. A restaurant was once part of the plan. By July 2024, the property's leasing agent told the Courier that no tenant had been chosen and that a restaurant was no longer the only possible use. The 5,236-square-foot mixed-use building next door, with five homes, was at the foundation stage as of the Courier's December 2025 update.
291 Second Avenue. The Rollman family ran Niwot Rental and Feed here for more than 41 years, until 2022. For two years after that, the new owner opened the building for art shows, receptions and rehearsals of the Niwot Community Semi-Marching Free Grange Band. Boulder County approved a site plan for the 9,426-square-foot building in 2025. According to the Courier's August 2025 report, it calls for four second-floor homes over ground-floor retail, restaurant or office space. As of December 2025, the lot was fenced off for redevelopment.
Those ground floors are where Second Avenue could gain new restaurants. The building at 121 Second Avenue shows one way a restaurant there can work, with an owner willing to lease to a kitchen and an operator who keeps the menu small. Taverna Laudisio serves dinner five nights a week, and Niwot Pizza delivers to Niwot from Ken Pratt Boulevard.
If you're wondering how Old Town's changes affect a home a few blocks from Second Avenue, Jane Kraemer can talk it through with you, one address at a time. Schedule Your Free Market Consultation.